Gustave Doré · Matthew 27:35
The Crucifixion of Jesus and Two Criminals
Matthew 27:35 · World English Bible (Catholic)
35When they had crucified him, they divided his clothing among them, casting lots,
A beam of light cuts through the clouds and descends toward the central cross. It reaches the body of Jesus, whose outstretched arms stand out against the dark sky. To his right, another condemned man is seen from behind; to his left, farther away, the third appears smaller. The three crosses do not form a regular row: their staggered arrangement gives depth to the place of execution and sets the central figure apart without separating him from the other two condemned men.
The space at the foot of the crosses remains open. The figures stand mostly to the sides: a group of veiled figures near the rock on the left, armed men and horsemen on the right. A horse occupies the foreground, much closer to us than the crucified men. The distance obliges us to raise our gaze beyond this military presence to reach Jesus. The beam from the sky then leads the eye back in the opposite direction, toward his body.
In Matthew, the crucifixion is described in a few words before attention turns to the garments divided and cast lots for. The verse links this act to a prophetic utterance. Here, no casting of lots is clearly discernible: it is the three bodies on the crosses that dominate the scene. The presence of the other two condemned men, absent from the passage cited, broadens the moment represented; the horsemen and gathered figures also give visible form to the surroundings of Golgotha.
The beam makes Jesus stand out among the condemned, but falls upon a body exposed like theirs. This light may be read in light of the prophetic words recalled by Matthew: at the very heart of the stripping away, the narrative recognizes the fulfillment of Scripture. The engraving allows us to see this stripping away without making visible the division that, in the verse, gives it measure.